Skip to main content

Does Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Look Better Without Cel Shading?


When the first trailer for the Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild hit, I was equal parts excited and disappointed. Simply put, it looked epic. It was the first time in years I was really pumped to get into a Zelda game.

The disappointment came from the use of cel shading.

Don't get me wrong; Breath of the Wild turned out beautiful. I don't mind games that focus on style over realism, and that's clearly the direction they took. Breath of the Wild is like a compromise between two radically different art directions—it has the cel shading made famous in Wind Waker, but with more realistically proportioned character models. It's a good middle ground, but it wasn't what I wanted. In the back of my mind, I kept thinking how a less anime style would look so much better in Breath of the Wild.

Thanks to gratuitous modding, we can now see for ourselves.



If you didn't know, yes—mods are possible in Breath of the Wild. I've seen some goofy applications of it, such as Link riding on Sonic or (Goddesses save me) playable Bowsette. Sadly (or perhaps fortunately), you won't be playing these on your Switch. Instead these work by running the Wii U version of the game through an emulator. Not exactly widely available, but still interesting to see what people come up with.

Watching this video, I can't help but think this is what I hoped Breath of the Wild could be. Without cel shading Breath of the Wild bears more resemblance to Twilight Princess (or even Ocarina of Time's Unreal Engine remake). I've always been drawn to the Zelda games that are less cartoony and more serious (Majora's Mask being my all-time favorite).

Here's another video, this time looking around Hyrule Field.


It just looks so... good. So right. Still just as vibrant and beautiful, but with a realism that (for me at least) makes it easier to connect with. I can only imagine how easy it would be to get lost in a game like this. For me, this could have pushed Breath of the Wild into a whole new category, an 11/10, beyond perfect.

But what about you? What do you think of Breath of the Wild without cel shading? Do you agree with me, or do you prefer the anime look? Let me know in the comments!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

10 Reasons Why A Hat In Time Is Better Than Mario Odyssey

Don't get me wrong—I love Super Mario Odyssey. There's no denying the level of polish and care put into that game, and it truly is the best Mario game in years.

It's just that there's this little indie game that's better.

Why Do I Suddenly Hate Minecraft?

I have a long history with Minecraft. My introduction to the game was also my first time playing or discussing games over the internet. It's no exaggeration to say Minecraft changed the trajectory of my life, and over the years I've clocked in countless hours in that blocky world.

So... why can I suddenly not stand it?
Why Minecraft Is Amazing First, let's discuss all the things I love about the game. The thing that's always stood out to me with Minecraft is how creative it is. Not that the game is creative—it presents a fairly generic world with a few clever designs peppered in—but that the game allows for player creativity.
Arguably, the whole point of Minecraft is expression. You are given a limitless world and a vast palette of materials to turn this "generic" world into something of your creation. Once while pondering Minecraft, I realized how much it captures the deeply human desire to make a mark on the world. Here you are, dropped into a natural worl…

I have boxes full of signed books to giveaway FREE!

So a little backstory here.

I self-publish all of my books through Amazon, and my books are printed-on-demand to keep overhead costs down and prevent me from needing a huge stock of books on hand. Works out great, overall I like it—but I didn't always do print-on-demand.

When Tale of the Wisconsin Werewolf first launched, I went directly to a printer and had a bunch of copies made up ahead of time. This didn't end up as the most efficient way for me going forward, and the formatting on those first prints aren't as professional as they are now, but it was a start.

Anyway, I thought all that old stock was gone by now—but I just stumbled upon two full boxes of them!

So here's the thing... I don't really want to keep this much stock around, and it's harder than its worth to sell them separately on Amazon. Which means it's time for some really awesome giveaways!

I hereby decree all Wednesdays in the near future to be "Werewolf Wednesday," and I will b…